Which is better, Humana or Cigna Healthcare for Medicare Advantage?

Neither is universally better — it depends on your ZIP, doctors, prescriptions, and budget. Humana typically wins when Strong national MA network, generous extras (dental, vision, OTC, fitness via SilverSneakers), HMO + PPO availability in most states. Cigna Healthcare typically wins when Strong customer service ratings. Integrated medical + pharmacy. Growing MA network in southern states. A free SilverEdge advisor consultation includes a real-time side-by-side comparison for your specific situation.

Does Humana or Cigna Healthcare have a larger network?

Humana has approximately ~6.4 million Medicare Advantage members, and Cigna Healthcare has approximately ~0.7 million. Network size varies dramatically by state and county. The right question is not 'who is bigger nationally' but 'who has my doctors and hospitals in-network in my ZIP'.

How do Humana and Cigna Healthcare compare on CMS Star Ratings?

Both carriers have plans across multiple star ratings. Humana plans typically rate 4.0 stars; Cigna Healthcare typically 3.5-4.0. Higher CMS Star Rating = better member outcomes + lower premiums. SilverEdge can identify the highest-rated plans available in your specific ZIP.

Can I switch between Humana and Cigna Healthcare mid-year?

Yes, but only during specific windows. The Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment Period (Jan 1 – Mar 31) allows one plan switch per year. The Annual Enrollment Period (Oct 15 – Dec 7) lets you switch for the following plan year. Special Enrollment Periods (qualifying life events) may also allow mid-year switches.

Medicare carrier comparison · 2026 plan year

Humana vs Cigna Healthcare: which Medicare plan wins?

A side-by-side look at how Humana and Cigna Healthcare compare for 2026 Medicare Advantage, Medigap, and Part D. Network size, star ratings, pharmacy preferred networks, and who each is genuinely the best fit for. Reviewed by licensed advisors who write these plans every day.

	Humana	Cigna Healthcare
Headquartered	Louisville, Kentucky	Bloomfield, Connecticut
MA members (US)	~6.4 million	~0.7 million
Typical CMS Star Rating	4.0 stars	3.5-4.0 stars
Preferred pharmacy	Walmart preferred network for Part D — major savings if you fill at Walmart, Sam's Club, or mail-order via Humana Pharmacy.	Express Scripts preferred network. Good mail-order pricing.
Best for	Strong national MA network, generous extras (dental, vision, OTC, fitness via SilverSneakers), HMO + PPO availability in most states.	Strong customer service ratings. Integrated medical + pharmacy. Growing MA network in southern states.
Watch out for	PPO networks narrower than HMO in some markets. Some plans require referrals to specialists.	Smaller MA market share than UHC/Humana — limited availability in northern + western states.
CMS reputation	Many MA plans rated 4.0-4.5 stars by CMS in 2025.	Customer service consistently above average. CMS star ratings improving.

Pick Humana when

Humana fits your life if…

Strong national MA network, generous extras (dental, vision, OTC, fitness via SilverSneakers), HMO + PPO availability in most states.
You fill prescriptions where Humana's preferred pharmacy network is convenient.
Your doctors and hospitals are confirmed in-network for Humana in your county.

Pick Cigna Healthcare when

Cigna Healthcare fits your life if…

Strong customer service ratings. Integrated medical + pharmacy. Growing MA network in southern states.
You fill prescriptions where Cigna Healthcare's preferred pharmacy network is convenient.
Your doctors and hospitals are confirmed in-network for Cigna Healthcare in your county.

The actual answer to "which is better"

Neither carrier is universally better. The right Medicare plan depends on three things: your doctors (must be in-network), your prescriptions (must be on the formulary at a manageable tier), and your total annual cost (premium + deductible + copays + max out-of-pocket). A licensed SilverEdge advisor compares both carriers — plus the 40+ other carriers in your county — on those three things in 15 minutes. Free.

Call (866) 534-1886 — free advisor comparison

Compare other carrier pairs

Researching multiple options? These are the comparisons SilverEdge clients run most often:

Humana vs UnitedHealthcare → Aetna vs Humana → UnitedHealthcare vs Aetna → WellCare vs Humana → Devoted Health vs Humana → See all comparisons →